BEFORE
AFTER · 30sAfter blemishes, dark circles are what my clients ask about most. Lightroom has no one-click fix for them, but a small brush mask with three or four sliders makes them much lighter in about a minute per photo. The goal is lighter, not gone. Under-eyes with no shadow at all look strange, and people notice even if they cannot say why.
Lightroom masking has Brush, Linear Gradient, Radial Gradient, Select Subject, Select Sky, Select Background and Select People, plus range masks for colour and luminance. For under-eyes, most of them are the wrong shape.
Select People gives you parts like Face Skin, Body Skin, Eyebrows, Eye Sclera, Iris and Pupil, Lips, Teeth and Hair. There is no under-eye part. Face Skin covers the whole face, so if you lift it, the cheeks and forehead go up too. Eye Sclera and Iris and Pupil are for the eyes themselves, not the skin below them.
So the right tool is the Brush. I paint the circle by hand. It takes about ten seconds per eye.
These numbers are starting points, not rules. Every face and every light is different, so judge by eye at 100% and at fit-to-screen.
The most common mistake is trying to smooth the dark circle away. Lightroom cannot separate tone from texture, so any softening in that area takes the fine lines and pores with it, and you get a flat grey patch under each eye. That patch is what makes an edit look fake.
So lift the light and fix the colour, but do not blur. At 100% you should still see the fine lines and pores, just lighter. Too bright is as bad as too dark: if the under-eye is brighter than the cheek next to it, back off. If you also want to soften the rest of the face, do it in a separate Face Skin mask, as in my Lightroom skin smoothing guide, not in the under-eye brush.
On a phone screen it is easy to overdo it, because small screens hide the edge of the mask. Zoom in close before you export.
A brush mask lifts the whole area by the same amount. Real dark circles are not even: they are deepest at the inner corner, there is a soft hollow under the lid, and often a small crease. Lightroom cannot follow that shape pixel by pixel, so you either leave the deepest part dark or make the lighter part too bright.
Photoshop dodge & burn does it properly. You lighten only the dark parts, stroke by stroke, and the texture stays because you only change the light. It is the same technique I use to even out the rest of the face: how to even skin tone in Photoshop. In my own work I do it with RetouchLab Skin Pro, my Photoshop plugin: one brush that does dodge & burn, frequency separation and tone evening, so under-eyes, blotches and uneven tone are one pass. Press Cmd/Ctrl+E in Lightroom, retouch, save, and the file comes back to your catalog.
RetouchLab Skin Pro is a Photoshop plugin, one Cmd/Ctrl+E away from Lightroom. One brush does dodge & burn, frequency separation and tone evening, so under-eyes get lighter and pores stay. Photoshop 2022 or newer, Mac and Windows.
GET MY FREE TRIAL →"Easy to control the strength of the effects, which helps maintain natural skin texture. A great tool that speeds up the whole process."
Augustinas Žukovas · Adobe Exchange review
It can make them much lighter. Paint a Brush mask under each eye, raise Exposure and Shadows a little and correct the colour with Temperature and Tint. Removing them completely usually looks unnatural.
As a starting point: Exposure +0.10 to +0.30, Shadows +10 to +25, Temperature +5 to +10 for blue circles, Tint slightly towards green for purple ones, Texture 0. Then adjust by eye at 100%.
No. Select People has parts like Face Skin, Eyebrows, Eye Sclera and Iris and Pupil, but no under-eye area. Face Skin would lift the whole face, so use the Brush instead.
Tap Masking, then + and Brush, and paint under the eyes. Raise Exposure and Shadows under Light, adjust Temp and Tint under Color, leave Texture at 0 and tap the check mark.
Usually Texture or Clarity was lowered in the under-eye mask, or Exposure was pushed too far. Set Texture and Clarity back to 0 and lower the mask's Amount until it blends with the cheek.
See it work → try the free live demo